Dear all,
This is my first post on Statalist, so please excuse any errors.
The paper in question is http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/1...ssa.12048/full. It is open access so I've attached the main article and online appendix for convenience as PDFs. The users also make available their .dta files and do-file in a .txt document, which is downloadable from http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/journ...Marcellino.zip - I've attached them unzipped version for convenience.
The authors used Stata 11 with the latest versions (at the time) of -xtivreg2-, -ivreg2-, -ranktest-, -bacon-. I'm running Stata 13 and have installed the latest versions of those programs.
What I've done so far is download the files, and run the relevant section of the _do.txt file for "TABLES 2, 3 and 4". In Table 2 of the main article (page 113 .pdf), I've been able to replicate columns (1) (3) and (5) but am unable to locate the numbers for the IV-2SLS baseline model in columns (2) (4) and (6). I would like some assistance to see if I'm missing something or if something has changed in the -xtivreg2- or -ivreg2- commands. In the attached "5 April 2016.txt" log file column (1) of Table 2 refers to line 221, column (3) refers to line 764 and column (5) refers to line 1493 (these are all Model 3.1 - where .1 refers to the basic OLS-FE model (line 138 of the _do.txt file ... "* OLS-FE model for comparison (TABLE 2)"). Columns (2) (4) and (6) are from my understanding the baseline Model 3.2 (line 142 of the _do.txt file).
This should give me appropriate results but in my "5 April 2016.txt" log file if you search for Model 3.2 from what I understand, lines 244-326 refer to Column (2) of Table 2 [mrc_ihme is under-5 mortality rate], lines 787-869 refer to Column (4) [mr_fem is female mortality rate] and lines 1518 to 1600 refer to Column (6) [mr_mal is male mortality rate]. For convenience I've attached a screenshot of Table 2 extracted with some annotations of the corresponding variable names in the Stata regression output.
I've also attached a .txt with Model 3.2 extracted from the full "5 April 2016.txt" log file.
Thank you for any assistance you can provide.
This is my first post on Statalist, so please excuse any errors.
The paper in question is http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/1...ssa.12048/full. It is open access so I've attached the main article and online appendix for convenience as PDFs. The users also make available their .dta files and do-file in a .txt document, which is downloadable from http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/journ...Marcellino.zip - I've attached them unzipped version for convenience.
The authors used Stata 11 with the latest versions (at the time) of -xtivreg2-, -ivreg2-, -ranktest-, -bacon-. I'm running Stata 13 and have installed the latest versions of those programs.
What I've done so far is download the files, and run the relevant section of the _do.txt file for "TABLES 2, 3 and 4". In Table 2 of the main article (page 113 .pdf), I've been able to replicate columns (1) (3) and (5) but am unable to locate the numbers for the IV-2SLS baseline model in columns (2) (4) and (6). I would like some assistance to see if I'm missing something or if something has changed in the -xtivreg2- or -ivreg2- commands. In the attached "5 April 2016.txt" log file column (1) of Table 2 refers to line 221, column (3) refers to line 764 and column (5) refers to line 1493 (these are all Model 3.1 - where .1 refers to the basic OLS-FE model (line 138 of the _do.txt file ... "* OLS-FE model for comparison (TABLE 2)"). Columns (2) (4) and (6) are from my understanding the baseline Model 3.2 (line 142 of the _do.txt file).
This should give me appropriate results but in my "5 April 2016.txt" log file if you search for Model 3.2 from what I understand, lines 244-326 refer to Column (2) of Table 2 [mrc_ihme is under-5 mortality rate], lines 787-869 refer to Column (4) [mr_fem is female mortality rate] and lines 1518 to 1600 refer to Column (6) [mr_mal is male mortality rate]. For convenience I've attached a screenshot of Table 2 extracted with some annotations of the corresponding variable names in the Stata regression output.
I've also attached a .txt with Model 3.2 extracted from the full "5 April 2016.txt" log file.
Thank you for any assistance you can provide.
Comment